The short version
Will the backup survive
the same failure?
Two Internet connections can improve resilience, but they may still depend on the same building entrance, fiber path, equipment, or power. The value of a backup depends on what it shares with the primary connection and how traffic moves when one fails.
Identify which applications and employees need to keep working, how much interruption they can tolerate, and what the backup must support.
There is no single design for every business. Document what is independent, what is shared, and what the providers cannot verify.
02 / Physical diversity
Follow the connection to the building.
Ask each provider about the route into the building, the entrance point, the riser to your floor, and the handoff location. Two connections can take different street paths but converge at the same building entrance or equipment room.
Where practical, separate entrances and internal pathways can reduce exposure to a single physical incident. Building design, permissions, available infrastructure, and construction costs determine what is possible. Providers may be unable to disclose or verify every part of another provider’s route.
03 / Inside the office
Check the equipment both links use.
Trace each connection from its handoff through the router, firewall, switches, and power. Separate providers cannot protect against a single device or power source that both services require.
Depending on the business, consider redundant routers or firewalls, separate power supplies and circuits, an uninterruptible power supply, and equipment in different locations. Redundancy adds cost and operational complexity; a second device still needs correct configuration, monitoring, and testing.
Include the office network and Wi-Fi in the plan. Internet failover does not help an employee whose access point, switch, or local device has failed.
04 / Provider & access choices
What does a second provider add?
Different providers may offer operational and network diversity, but different names do not prove different infrastructure. One provider may lease access from another, or both may use the same building facilities, upstream network, or physical route.
Ask where each provider’s service terminates or connects to its network, and whether the two services depend on the same data center, carrier hotel, or other critical facility. A shared facility can introduce common risks, such as an outage affecting its power, cooling, or access. Separate buildings can reduce some shared risks, but do not establish that the paths, power, or upstream networks are independent.
Providers may not be able to disclose every facility or verify another provider’s design. Ask them to describe the relevant shared dependencies and what they can confirm.
A backup using a different access technology, such as wireless, may avoid some wired-path risks. It has its own constraints, including coverage, signal conditions, capacity, power, and service terms. Evaluate the actual design and performance rather than assuming one technology is independent of another.
05 / Moving traffic
What happens when the primary fails?
Some businesses keep a backup idle until it is needed; others use both connections. In either case, the router or firewall must detect the failure and route traffic over the available path. Monitoring should test the right things: a physical link can remain up while a service or destination is unreachable.
Automatic failover is not always instantaneous. Existing calls, VPNs, or application sessions may disconnect or need to reconnect, especially if the public IP address changes. Applications that restrict source IP addresses may also require updates. Test the actual services your employees use.
Depending on the requirements, a design may use device-based failover, software-defined WAN, or BGP routing. BGP and provider-independent addresses can be appropriate in some multihomed networks, but they do not by themselves guarantee seamless failover, physical diversity, or unchanged application sessions. Ask your network team to design and test the approach.
Both connections may also depend on the same DNS service. Our business DNS guide covers resolver dependencies and resilience.
06 / Backup capacity
What must keep working?
The backup does not always need to match the primary circuit. List the applications, users, and locations that must remain operational, then estimate the upload and download capacity they require during an outage. Include VPN traffic, voice and video, cloud applications, and any workloads that cannot be deferred.
If the backup has less capacity, decide which traffic can wait and how essential applications will be protected from congestion. Check the backup’s latency, data limits, service terms, and equipment capacity. See our bandwidth planning guide for a sizing method.
07 / Validate the plan
Test it before an outage.
- 01
Agree on the test
Choose a maintenance window, define success, notify affected teams, and prepare a rollback plan. A test may interrupt active sessions.
- 02
Test representative failures
With the responsible teams, test loss of the primary service and, where appropriate, upstream reachability—not only an unplugged cable. Confirm which condition caused the switchover.
- 03
Check the work
Confirm the backup path, required applications, VPNs, voice, and public-facing services. Record interruption time, capacity, and anything that needs to reconnect.
- 04
Restore and document
Check the return to normal, record the outcome and open issues, and repeat testing after meaningful changes or on an agreed schedule.
08 / Planning checklist
Questions for providers and your IT team.
- Which physical routes, entrances, risers, and equipment rooms are separate? What cannot be verified?
- Do the services share a last-mile provider, upstream network, conduit, or building facility?
- Do they depend on the same data center or carrier hotel? What shared facility, power, or cooling risks can the providers confirm?
- What equipment and power must remain available for each connection?
- What failure does the monitoring detect, and how long did failover take in a test?
- Will public IP addresses change? Which VPNs, allowlists, or applications depend on them?
- Can the backup carry essential upload and download traffic at acceptable latency?
- How are the backup and the return to normal monitored and tested?
- Who owns each part of the design, and whom do we call during an incident?
For a Stealth service discussion, contact sales@stealth.net. Existing customers can contact support at +1 212 232 2020 or support@stealth.net.
About this brief
About this guide.
These references discuss shared network risks and testing redundant connections. Their guidance addresses different environments; apply it to your own service and design.
Shared infrastructure
- CISA: Network resiliencyPublic-safety guidance on provider and route diversity
- IETF RFC 3386Shared risks in network paths
Failover & recovery
- AWS: Direct Connect failover testingAn example of testing a BGP peering failure
- AWS: Test connectivity and failoverTesting redundant connections and recovery
Prepared by Stealth Communications, a provider of business connectivity. A resilience design depends on the actual facilities, service agreements, equipment, and business requirements.